$560 to spend on a rear bumper-- Suggestions???

Car in question: White 4Dr 95 Civic LX

Got rear-ended this weekend and the lady didn't want to claim on insurance so I'm getting a check. I need a new rear bumper and the body shop quoted $560 for a new OEM bumper and paint, etc.
($300 for the bumper and $200 to paint it)

So I'm thinking maybe get a Body Kit bumper and go for a stock improvement?

Or maybe just get a cheaper OEM (ebay) and some lips and side skirts?

Which rear bumper do you guys like? I've never looked for these before..
So far I've found these but I can't make up my mind Are there others you would recommend? best prices?

shoot all your suggestions my way
thx