Good points so far guys. I certainly am against torture for the hell of it, but if we have reason to believe a terrorist is witholding information that could save lives, it is my strong belief that we should do anything and everything possible to try to extract that information. The problem is the media and the public. Torturing for information is happening; make no mistake. However, it hasn't leaked yet (except Abu Grahb sp?). I'm not arguing the morality of torture, as that is a whole other issue. I think first we should focus on the
legality (of lack thereof) of torture.
Steve, what you posted is very interesting. Might I point out one line;
Quote:
(b) that of having a fixed distinctive sign recognizable at a distance; (c) that of carrying arms openly; (d) that of conducting their operations in accordance with the laws and customs of war.
|
The thing that strikes me most about this is that they DO NOT have a sign/uniform. Therefore they do not meet all conditions required to apply to the Geneva Convention.